Another twist on our discussion of brain patterns, personality and ability to transfer data between human beings (to network them like computers). A new movie, Self/Less, has the premise of fully memory and personality transfer of human consciousness.
When business tycoon Damien Hale (played by Ben Kingsley) faces death from cancer in Self/Less,
in theaters today, he doesn’t go gently into that good night. Instead,
he undergoes a radical underground medical procedure called “shedding”
that allows him to transfer his mind into another, younger, healthier,
lab-grown body (Ryan Reynolds’s body, to be exact) and start a whole new
life with a new identity.
For now, this is science fiction—but, says Charles Higgins, a neuroscientist at the University of Arizona, it could one day happen.
“We cannot yet conceive of a machine that could scan the brain to the
extent required to do what is in the movie,” he tells mental_floss.
“But 100 years ago we could not conceive that in our pockets we would
carry what are, essentially, supercomputers and communicators that we
can talk to anyone on the planet with.”
Studying the brain is Higgins's business. “I’m interested in the
interface between the mind and the brain and quantifying things that are
normally unquantifiable, like depression, mood, consciousness, and
self,” he says. Among the things he and his team are working on in his research laboratory:
grabbing electrical signals from insect brains to build high-tech
robots with excellent vision; figuring out how cognition works by
creating a simulated, computerized rat that wanders around a digital
maze; and gathering data on human sleep with a device he built. So
though he didn’t consult on Self/Less during production—the studio brought him on afterward—he’s an excellent source to talk to about the film’s science.
According to Higgins, there are huge hurdles to jump before we transfer
consciousness from one body to another. For one, there’s a lot we don’t
understand about how the brain—and consciousness in particular—work. “If
you ask 100 different experts to list what the brain does, you’ll get
100 different answers,” Higgins says. “The brain definitely regulates
your life support. Sometimes we use the word cognition—is that what the brain does? It’s a memory system as well. You could go on and on.”
Once we understand the brain in the same way we
understand the heart or a computer, Higgins says, “we’ll be able to see
how brains are related and understand what the important details we need
to get out of the brain are.”
Another challenge: Computers have software, but the
brain isn’t quite so simple. “The software and the hardware are all
[together],” Higgins says. “So what details of the brain structure do I
need to read out?”
Some people, he says, think we need to go down to a
quantum level. Others think it might be unnecessary to go subatomic to
scan consciousness: “You could go just to the level of of neurons and
other connections,” Higgins says. “But we don’t really know.”
Even if we did know where consciousness was found, we don’t have the technology to transfer it. In Self/Less,
the company Phoenix Biogenic uses what looks like a souped-up fMRI
(functional magnetic resonance imaging) to access and transfer
consciousness from one body to another. Higgins says this is “the right
idea, although at this point fMRI technology does not allow us to get
down to sub-neuron resolution.”
Computers use electromagnetic markers to store and access data. The human brain uses biochemicals and proteins to make connections to organic synapses. Science does not know how the brain encodes memories, emotions and data for storage and later retrieval. Medical science does not know why in the aging process, people begin to lose memories. Rehab therapists have trained patients to mentally use artificial, mechanical limbs.
The next step in research is to find how a person's mind interacts with his or her organic materials in the brain.
A delusion is a belief held by an individual or group that is demonstrably false, patently untrue, impossible, fanciful, or self-deceptive. A person with delusions, however, often has complete certainty and conviction about their delusory beliefs. They resist arguments and evidence that they are wrong.
People have illusions about smells (olfactory), taste (gustatory), temperature (thermoceptive), and touch (tactile). They may experience highly disgusting or very pleasant or unusual smells when meeting a particular person. They may find ordinary foods (oranges, chocolate, milk) have different tastes than others experience. They may find cool objects burning hot or warm objects frozen; traditionally smooth objects (like a balloon or cat's fur) may feel rough or uneven.
The most written about of all delusions, paranoia, has been shown to follow various stages: general suspiciousness; selective perception of others; hostility; paranoid “illumination” in which all things fall into place; and, finally, paradoxical delusions of influence and persecution. Delusions often totally preoccupy people and cause them considerable distress because they do not doubt their beliefs are correct.
Delusions differ from illusions. We have visionary and auditory illusions; for instance, that the sun goes around the earth or that ventriloquists’ dummies actually speak. We have selective memories /illusions of happy childhoods. These are things that seem true to the senses or memory, but are known to be false or have no basis in reality.
There are some caveats: Some religious delusions are impossible to verify and hence falsify. Other delusions have a self-fulfilling prophecy, such as a jealous person accusing and attacking an innocent partner, who then leaves them for another. In that sense, these people cause their delusions to come true.
An emotional charge, like jealous, can tap a person's brain process and imagination to create false presumptions and assumptions that feed fear and paranoia. If a girlfriend does not return a message, an insecure boyfriend could begin the dark road of self-esteem hits to his own ego: maybe she no longer likes me?, who is she with?, is she out with another man?, where is she? is she having a good time without me? This self doubt has a cascade effect which could lead to the irrational boyfriend to lash out at his innocent girlfriend who was merely too busy at work to respond to his messages. So his fear about losing her is a self-induced reality caused by his delusions about an event which he lacks sufficient information to make a rational decision. The idea of "self-fulfilling prophecy" comes to mind.
Psychiatrists may diagnose someone as having a delusion disorder under a number of very specific situations:
- The disturbance is not the result of physiological or medical conditions, like the medication or drugs a person is taking.
Sometimes psychiatrists say it is difficult to distinguish from other disorders like hypochondriasis (particularly among those with little self-awareness); body dysmorphic disorder (preoccupation with imagined bodily defects); Obsessive Compulsive as well as Paranoid Personality Disorder.The delusions of people with schizophrenia are often clearly bizarre, utterly implausible, not at all understandable; one might believe the brain has been replaced by that of another person or that one has shrunk to be three feet tall. On the other hand, non-bizarre delusions could be possible. For instance, people may feel they are being followed, photographed or recorded, that somebody is slowly poisoning them, that their partner is always cheating onthem, or that their boss or neighbor is in love with them. A person can easily project negatives onto any situation because their minds are free to make blind speculations about the world around them. A person with low esteem or is self-centered can channel these negatives into a web of "the world is against me" personality traits. Or that "I am cursed because I am unlucky at everything."
Some delusions cause people to make dramatic changes in their life: leave their job or partner, move from their house (or even leave the country), or dress very differently. The person with delusional disorder, however, appears normal when their delusional ideas are not being discussed.
People with delusions can become very moody, often causing their relationships and work to suffer. Interestingly, some cultures and groups have particular beliefs that may in other cultures be seen as clinically delusional.
It is a relatively rare disorder usually occurring later in life, particularly among people with relatives who have other disorders. Most appear argumentative and hypersensitive. Many do not seek treatment and become, over the years, more and more isolated.
Psychiatrists have noticed five clear types of delusions:
- Somatic. This is the delusion that one’s body is
somehow strange or not functioning properly. It may be the belief that
one smells odd, or that particular parts (nose, breasts, feet) are
particularly odd, misshapen or ugly. Often people with these delusions
believe they may have some internal bug or parasite that is destroying
or affecting some very specific part of their body.
The causes of delusions are unknown. Current interests in neuropsychology have lead some to speculate that malfunctioning biological features may cause or exacerbate the problem. Some have implicated basal ganglia, others the limbic system and still others the neocortex. Investigations continue.For others, genetic explanations are best because so many with delusional disorders have first-degree relatives with these and related disorders.Other researchers point out that many with the disorder have had difficult childhoods characterized by instability and turbulence, callousness and coldness. They consider delusions to be an impairment in the ego defense system aimed to protect and bolster the self. They see the paranoid or persecutory delusions as an attempt to project onto others things they do not like to admit in themselves.
People often lie, fake, or deceive, even to themselves. Psychologists call this dissimulation, but have recently distinguished between two very different types of dissimulation: